PLAYCALLER
NFL · Start or Sit

Should I Start Devin Singletary or J.J. McCarthy?

Data-driven NFL fantasy start/sit decision. Recent game logs, trend analysis, and a verdict based on actual performance — not gut feel.

Start this week
J.J. McCarthy
Based on recent average (14.4 pts) and trend vs Devin Singletary (9.3 pts)
Devin Singletary
RB · NYG · NFL
9.3
avg pts (8g)
5.1
std dev
→ steady
last 4g
Last 5 games
5.9W9
14.5W7
4.3W6
13.8W1
10.6W18
VS
▶ Start this week
J.J. McCarthy
QB · NYG · NFL
14.4
avg pts (8g)
6.1
std dev
▼ trending down
last 4g
Last 5 games
18.1W10
7.3W9
10.2W7
17.3W6
8W18

Get a roster-specific start/sit decision

This is league-agnostic context. PlayCaller knows your exact roster, scoring settings, and weekly matchups — and gives you a decision made for your lineup, not a generic comparison.

Try Free for 7 Days →

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I start Devin Singletary or J.J. McCarthy?
Based on recent performance, start J.J. McCarthy. J.J. McCarthy averages 14.4 fantasy points over their last 8 games. See the full comparison and trend data on this page.
What is Devin Singletary's fantasy value right now?
Devin Singletary has averaged 9.3 fantasy points over their last 8 games this season, with a steady trend. Standard deviation of 5.1 points — a relatively consistent floor.
What is J.J. McCarthy's fantasy value right now?
J.J. McCarthy has averaged 14.4 fantasy points over their last 8 games this season, with a down trend. Standard deviation of 6.1 points — a relatively consistent floor.

More NFL start/sit decisions

NFL RB RankingsNFL WR Rankings Weekly Rankings Devin Singletary Profile J.J. McCarthy Profile